LAB-GROWN VS NATURAL DIAMONDS
THE SIMPLE TRUTH
Lab-grown diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds. Both have the same hardness, brilliance, and fire. Both are graded by the same standards.
The only difference is origin. Natural diamonds form over billions of years deep in the earth. Lab diamonds grow in weeks using technology that replicates natural conditions.
The FTC confirmed in 2018 that lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds. GIA and IGI grade them using the same 4Cs system. Even experts cannot tell them apart without specialized equipment.
ARE LAB DIAMONDS REAL
Yes. Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds. They have the same chemical composition and crystal structure as natural diamonds. Pure carbon arranged in a cubic crystal structure.
They are not diamond simulants like cubic zirconia or moissanite. Those are different materials entirely. Lab diamonds are actual diamonds grown in controlled conditions.
Traditional gemological tools cannot tell them apart. To identify origin, labs use specialized equipment that detects trace elements. Natural diamonds contain tiny amounts of nitrogen. Lab diamonds typically do not.
HOW THEY FORM
Different processes. Same result. Understanding how each forms explains why they are identical.
NATURAL DIAMONDS
Form 100 to 200 kilometers below the earth's surface. Extreme pressure and temperatures between 900-1300°C crystallize carbon over 1 to 3 billion years. Volcanic eruptions bring them to the surface. Most diamonds are older than dinosaurs.
LAB-GROWN DIAMONDS
Two methods replicate natural conditions. HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) mimics earth's mantle. CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) grows diamonds from carbon gas. Both produce real diamonds in weeks to months. Same crystal structure. Same properties.
THE PRICE DIFFERENCE
Lab diamonds cost significantly less. This is the main reason people choose them.
THE PRICE GAP
Lab-grown diamonds cost 60-90% less than natural diamonds of the same quality. A 1-carat lab diamond with excellent cut, E color, and VS2 clarity costs a fraction of the identical natural diamond. Same appearance. Different price.
LARGER STONES
The price advantage increases with carat weight. A 2-carat lab diamond can cost less than a tenth of what an equivalent natural diamond costs. This makes larger stones more accessible.
WHY THE DIFFERENCE
Mining operations are expensive. Exploration, excavation, processing, and distribution add costs. Lab production is controlled and scalable. Supply has increased faster than demand, driving prices down.
VALUE RETENTION
Natural diamonds hold value better. Lab diamond prices have dropped over 80% between 2015 and 2024. This trend may continue as production increases.
Lab diamonds have minimal resale value. You will not recover much of your purchase price. Natural diamonds retain more value, though they also depreciate from retail prices.
Neither is a good investment compared to gold or stocks. Buy based on what you want to wear, not what you hope to sell later. If resale matters, choose natural. If resale does not matter, lab diamonds offer better value.
QUALITY & APPEARANCE
Both types show the same brilliance, fire, and sparkle. Same optical properties. Same light performance. You cannot tell them apart by looking.
Lab diamonds often achieve higher clarity and color grades. The controlled growth environment produces fewer inclusions. Finding a colorless VVS lab diamond costs less than the natural equivalent.
Both are graded by GIA and IGI using the same 4Cs standards. A VS2 G color lab diamond looks identical to a VS2 G color natural diamond. The grades mean the same thing.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
Lab diamonds have a smaller environmental footprint. The difference is significant but not zero-impact.
NATURAL DIAMOND MINING
- • Produces 5,800 pounds of mineral waste per carat
- • Disturbs up to 100 square feet of land per carat
- • Causes soil erosion and deforestation
- • Uses significant water resources
- • Creates habitat destruction
LAB DIAMOND PRODUCTION
- • Requires high energy consumption
- • No land disturbance or mining waste
- • Uses less water than mining
- • Can use renewable energy sources
- • Lower carbon footprint overall
THE HONEST ASSESSMENT
Lab diamonds are better for the environment than mining. Energy use remains a concern, especially if production relies on fossil fuels. Producers using renewable energy achieve the best environmental profile. Second-hand diamonds of either type have the lowest impact.
MARKET TRENDS
Lab diamonds are gaining market share rapidly. In 2024, 52% of couples surveyed chose lab-grown diamonds for engagement rings according to The Knot's Real Weddings Study. This marks a significant shift.
Younger buyers prefer lab diamonds. Price and environmental concerns drive the choice. Traditional buyers still favor natural diamonds for their rarity and value retention.
Both markets will continue. Lab diamonds appeal to value-conscious and environmentally-minded buyers. Natural diamonds appeal to those prioritizing rarity, tradition, and investment value.
WHICH TO CHOOSE
CHOOSE LAB-GROWN IF YOU
- • Want a larger or higher-quality diamond for your budget
- • Plan to keep the ring forever
- • Prioritize environmental impact
- • Value what the diamond represents over its origin
- • Want maximum sparkle for minimum cost
- • Prefer conflict-free guaranteed sourcing
CHOOSE NATURAL IF YOU
- • Value rarity and natural formation
- • Want better resale value
- • Prefer traditional heirloom appeal
- • Like the idea of a billions-year-old stone
- • View the diamond as an investment
- • Want established secondary market options
COMMON QUESTIONS
Can anyone tell the difference?
No. Not with the naked eye. Not even jewelers can tell without specialized equipment. Both look identical. Both perform identically. Only advanced testing reveals the origin.
Do lab diamonds get cloudy over time?
No. Lab diamonds do not change over time. They remain as brilliant as the day they were created. This myth has no scientific basis. Clean them like any diamond to maintain sparkle.
Will people judge my choice?
Most people cannot tell and will not ask. Fifty-two percent of couples now choose lab diamonds. The stigma is disappearing. Your choice matters more than others' opinions.
Can I mix lab and natural diamonds?
Yes. Many rings use lab-grown center stones with natural diamond accents, or vice versa. They look identical when set together. Choose based on your budget for each stone.
Are lab diamonds insurable?
Yes. Insurance companies cover lab diamonds the same as natural diamonds. They insure based on the replacement value. Get an appraisal from a certified gemologist for both types.
STILL DECIDING?
We offer both lab-grown and natural diamonds. No pressure. Honest advice to help you choose what fits your values and budget.