Skip to main content

Old Mine Cut Diamond

Jared James, co-founder of LILY DIA

By Jared James · Last updated 21 May 2026

Quick answer

An old mine cut diamond is an antique cushion-shaped cut, hand-cut from roughly the early 1700s through to the late 1800s, long before electric light and modern faceting. It has a soft, squarish outline, a tall crown, a small table and a large open culet that shows as a little circle in the centre, and it was cut to glow under candlelight rather than to throw out the bright sparkle of a modern brilliant. No two are quite alike, so each stone is judged on its own.

Shape at a glance

Outline of an old mine diamond shape
The outline helps you judge ratio and setting balance before comparing individual diamond reports.
Old Mine Cut Diamond quick facts
DetailTypical detailBuying note
Facet patternAntique brilliant faceting, all cut by hand.Every old mine cut is a little different, so each stone has to be judged on its own.
OutlineA soft, slightly squarish cushion shape.Old mine cuts predate standard ratios, so expect gentle, uneven curves rather than a precise outline.
SparkleA soft, warm glow with broad flashes, made for candlelight.An old mine cut will not sparkle like a modern brilliant, and that gentle look is the appeal.
Best forAntique and vintage rings, and bezel or low-set heirloom styles.Choose an old mine cut when you want genuine antique character and history.

What is an Old Mine Cut Diamond?

An old mine cut diamond is an antique cut, the kind of stone set in jewellery from roughly the early eighteenth century through to the late nineteenth. It has a soft, squarish cushion outline with rounded corners, a tall crown, a small flat table on top and a large culet, the facet at the very bottom, which was left open and reads as a small circle when you look down into the stone.

Every old mine cut was shaped and polished by hand, often by eye and by candlelight, well before electric light or the precise cutting tools used today. That is why no two are quite the same, and why they have a soft, glowing look rather than the sharp, bright sparkle of a modern brilliant. The name came later, from the diamond trade, to describe stones from the old mines of India and Brazil that were worked before the South African finds of the late 1800s.

A loose old mine cut diamond face up, a soft squarish cushion outline with chunky facets
An old mine cut face up: a soft, squarish outline with broad, chunky facets.
Side-on photo of a 2.01 carat D VVS1 old mine cut lab-grown diamond, with its table, tall crown and open culet labelled, by Lily Dia Jewellery
A real 2.01 carat old mine cut side on: a tall crown and a flat, open culet at its base.

Where the old mine cut comes from

The old mine cut belongs to the long stretch of diamond history before cutting became a precise, standardised craft. From the early 1700s onwards, cutters worked rough diamonds by hand, following the natural shape of the crystal to save as much weight as they could, which is why old mine cuts kept a soft, squarish outline and a deep, chunky build. They were cut for the light of the time, candlelight and lamplight, where a tall crown and broad facets gave a warm, flickering glow.

By the late nineteenth century the old mine cut had evolved into the old European cut, a rounder shape made possible by better tools, and in 1919 the modern round brilliant set out the proportions still used today. Genuine old mine cuts now come mostly from antique jewellery, which is a large part of their appeal, and the style had a fresh moment of attention through vintage-inspired engagement rings, including the old mine brilliant cut Taylor Swift wore in her widely shared 2025 engagement ring.

What to check before choosing

Every old mine cut is unique

Old mine cuts were never cut to a standard, so each one is its own stone, with its own outline, depth and facet pattern. Buy the individual diamond in front of you rather than a grade on paper, and look at it in person or on video to see how it actually behaves in the light.

Expect a soft glow, not bright sparkle

An old mine cut will not flash like a modern brilliant, and it is not meant to. It gives a warmer, gentler return of light, with broad flashes and a visible culet through the centre. If you love that antique character it is exactly right, and if you want maximum sparkle a modern cut will suit you better.

Old mine cut or a modern recut?

Some antique stones have been recut into modern shapes over the years, and some modern diamonds are cut today in an old mine style. Ask whether a stone is a genuine antique or a modern interpretation, because it affects both the character and the price, and a grading report or an independent valuation can help confirm it.

Settings that suit this shape

  • A bezel or a low, simple setting protects an antique stone and suits its understated character.
  • Yellow and rose gold tend to flatter old mine cuts, since many carry a little warmth and were made for warm light.
  • Antique-style details like milgrain, engraving and a detailed gallery sit naturally with the cut and its era.
An old mine cut solitaire with white claws on a slim yellow gold band
An old mine cut in a slim yellow gold solitaire with white claws.

Who does old mine suit?

Old mine cut suits anyone who wants a diamond with real history and a soft, candlelit glow rather than bright modern sparkle. It is a lovely choice for vintage and antique-style engagement rings, and for anyone who likes the idea of a stone that is genuinely one of a kind.

Watch for

  • Old mine cuts give a soft glow, so they can look less bright than a modern cut, especially in harsh light.
  • Quality varies enormously from stone to stone, because each one was cut by hand to a different standard.
  • Genuine antiques can carry small chips or wear from a long life, so check the condition closely.
An elongated old mine cut solitaire with white claws on a yellow gold band
An elongated old mine cut in the same simple setting.

Watch: thinking of buying an old mine cut?

A quick look at what to weigh up before you choose an old mine cut diamond.

Ready to compare

See old mine engagement rings

Browse old mine engagement rings and compare how the shape behaves across solitaire, halo and custom settings.

View old mine rings

Frequently asked questions

What is an old mine cut diamond?
An old mine cut diamond is an antique cushion-shaped cut, hand-cut from roughly the early 1700s to the late 1800s. It has a soft squarish outline, a tall crown, a small table and a large open culet, and it was cut to glow under candlelight rather than to sparkle like a modern brilliant.
What is the difference between an old mine cut and an old European cut?
They are two stages of the same antique tradition. The old mine cut came first and has a soft, squarish cushion outline. As cutting tools improved in the late 1800s it evolved into the old European cut, which is rounder and a step closer to the modern round brilliant.
What is the difference between an old mine cut and a cushion cut?
A modern cushion cut shares the soft squarish outline, but it is cut today with modern tools and faceting for bright, even sparkle. An old mine cut is the antique original, cut by hand with a tall crown and a large open culet, so it has a softer, warmer and less uniform look.
Are old mine cut diamonds valuable?
They can be. Value depends on the individual stone, its size, colour, clarity and condition, and on whether it is a genuine antique. Many buyers also value the history and the fact that each one is unique, which a standard grading report does not capture.
Why is it called an old mine cut?
The name comes from the diamond trade. It refers to stones cut from the older diamond sources, the mines of India and Brazil, that were worked before the large South African discoveries of the late 1800s. The term came into use later to set these antique stones apart from newer ones.
Are old mine cut diamonds good for engagement rings?
Yes, if you love antique character. Old mine cuts are durable enough for daily wear, though a genuine antique should be checked for chips and wear and set protectively. They are a beautiful choice for vintage-inspired engagement rings where history is part of the appeal.

Still comparing shapes

Ask us to compare your shortlist

Send the shapes or ring styles you are considering and we will help you compare proportion, setting style and everyday wear, by video call, phone or email.

Book a video consultation